Tuesday, November 14, 2006

airing your dirty laundry, Mormon style

The following are some examples of where matters as private as underwear become public in Mormonism:

Among many Mormons, there may be a change of clothing style to make sure garments are hidden: longer shorts, longer sleeves, higher necklines (particularly in females). I had always avoided sleeveless shirts, though I had to get rid of some too-short shorts. Why I thought thighs were okay to show, while upper arms were not, I don't know. Also, it was, in my case at least, well known among extended family and friends when I went to the temple for the first time, and hence started wearing garments.

Additionally, there may be visible garment-lines at the neck, knees, and upper arms. Short shirts in females may reveal the garment-covered midriff. Talk may occur between insiders about styles, fabrics, annoyances, where to find long shorts, how to get away with a lower neckline, how getting away with a lower neckline is evil, etc.

Garment-checking culture was especially strong at BYU. Checking for "the smile," the dipping neckline in some men's style of garments, was a common way among my acquaintances to determine if a male BYU student was a return missionary (RM) or not (and hence potential future-husband material or not). I am embarrassed to admit that I checked for the smile on my now-husband to figure out if he was an RM or not. I was confused when I didn't see the smile. (It was because he wore crew neck garments, which I didn't know existed.)

Another technique I learned at BYU was to sit down next to a guy and place a hand on his knee to feel for a garment line. He just thinks you're flirting, but really you're checking for a marker of his righteousness. Yep, I used that one too. Awful. Just once, on a guy I was just starting to date. And I actually had the audacity to say something when I didn't feel or see a knee line. (He explained he was wearing the long-john thermal version.) It seems so intrusive and overly-personal to me now, but then it seemed normal. I had to know if I was wasting time on a non-temple-marriageable guy, right?

I suppose the garment-checking dynamics operated differently for men looking for women at BYU, since fewer women were
RMs and/or garment-wearing. Especially since some men didn't want to marry a female RM.

While I was a faithful Mormon, it never occurred to me that having a church tell me to wear their garments was weird. I just grew up with it. When the bishops and stake presidents in temple recommend interviews asked me if I was "wearing the temple garment night and day," I just considered it as part of their job. And it was my duty to tell them yes or no (and it was always yes). It was only after I left that I realized how utterly inappropriate it is for a church to regulate my underwear.

Monday, November 13, 2006

conversation with a preschooler

We have various neighbors who are devoutly Muslim, Jewish, and Catholic. There are also Hindus, atheists, and every variety of Christian. And, of course, most of our extended family is Mormon. So our son is not unaccustomed to hearing "Because they're Muslim" or "Because they think that's what God wants them to do" when he asks, "Why do they do that?" I also try to explain a little about the different religions when he asks, and I hope he will understand diversity.

For example, on Halloween, when he wanted to knock on our Muslim friends' door, I asked him not to. I knew they considered Halloween a pagan holiday, to be avoided at all cost. When he asked why, I said, "They don't celebrate Halloween because they are Muslim. But they have other great holidays that we don't have, like Ramadan, when they eat a big meal with all their friends every night for a month. And Eid ul Fitr, when they get to go to a carnival, and get new clothes." I didn't want him to think his friends are weird or deprived just because they don't dress up like vampires and dinosaurs and fairies and ask strangers for candy. ('Cause that's not weird at all.)

Yesterday was a rainy one, so we couldn’t go outside to play. He was bummed that he couldn’t be outside with friends. Out the window, he saw his friend walking up the street with his dad.

“Do you think Levi will stay outside and play?” he asked hopefully.
“No, it’s still pretty wet.”
“Do you think Ali and Hakim will come out?”
“Probably not,” I answered.
“Can Muslims not have rain boots?” he asked, trying to figure out what might be preventing his friends from coming out.
“Oh, no, Muslims can wear rain boots. And Levi’s not Muslim, he’s Jewish.”
“What do Jewish people do?”
“They go to synagogue—that’s like church—on Saturday, and they sing certain songs, and lots of them speak Hebrew” I stalled, trying to find a way to explain ritual, heritage, and ethnicity to a preschooler. “But not all Jews do that. David is Jewish, and his family doesn’t do any of that.”

Then he looked at me seriously and said, “I want to be something. I want to have something like that.”

He wanted an identity. He wanted to know what he can be.

I panicked. I’m not sure what I believe. I’m not sure what my identity is. While the closest things I can claim are Mormon and atheist, I don’t want to identify as the former, and I don’t feel the latter as an community or an identity per se.

I blurted out, “We have science,” thinking of the character in Nacho Libre that “believes in science.” I felt stupid. I couldn’t even figure out what to say to my child. While I have no trouble saying, “Muslims believe this, Christians believe that, some people do this,” I couldn’t figure out how to explain what I believe. Or better yet, how to encourage him to figure out what he believes.

Later at dinner, I recounted the conversation to my husband. He turned to our son and said, “You want to be something, huh?”
“Yeah,” our son said, “but I know what I want to be. I’m a pirate.”
“Great,” I joked, “that means you have the Flying Spaghetti Monster as your god.”
“The Flying Spaghetti Monster? What’s that?”
“The god of the pirates. I’ll show you a picture.” And we pulled out the Gospel of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, a book I got my husband for fun. Our son really liked the pictures and the connection to pirates, and quickly adopted the symbol of the fossilized fish as “my symbol,” lover, as he is, of fossils. He kept saying, “The Flying Spaghetti Monster is my god. ‘Cause I’m a pirate. David too, because he’s a pirate too.”

“This is the perfect thing for you to blurt out while we’re visiting Grandma and Grandpa in Utah,” I said, more to my husband than to my son. Better that than “My dad likes beer, but my mom likes wine.”

He was really getting into it, and I started to worry. Okay, so now my little joke was going a little too far.

“Is the Flying Spaghetti Monster real or just pretend?” I asked him.
“Oh, he’s real. He’s real. He’s just hiding.”
“Where?”
“Um, where no one, no one can ever find him. Deep, deep down in dirt.”
“What about Jesus? Is Jesus real or pretend?”
“Pretend,” he answered with confidence. (I never told him that, just for the record.)

Great, I thinking. My kid believes in Santa Claus and the Flying Spaghetti Monster, but thinks God is just pretend. If he thought all were pretend, I'd be fine, but why choose Santa Claus and a god made of pasta as plausible entities? Wondering what to do, I realize I don’t really have to do anything right now. Because he’s a preschooler: Within 30 seconds, he was more preoccupied with saying “Ahoy thar, ye matey” and his collection of hot wheels than gods or identity.

But I think it will be healthy for him to be able to identify with some identity, though I don’t think it has to be a religious one. And to help him learn that identity, I should figure out what my identity is.

Sunday, November 12, 2006

marriage covenant

I once read on a faithful Mormon board a thread about in-out marriages. That is, one spouse has left the church, the other is still a faithful believer. Most agreed that divorce was the best option. (This is a pro-family religion?) “After all,” one poster said, “if the apostate spouse has broken the temple covenants, how can the faithful spouse trust him/her to keep the marriage covenants?”

Given what I’ve said about the irrelevance and dissolving of church covenants, and given that marriage is one of the temple covenants, the poster’s comment was—albeit appalling—somewhat fair for the question to arise. It does, at the very least, cross people’s minds.

As I’ve posted before, I called everything into question when my Mormon world view shattered. Everything. Some things were easy to resolve and rebuild, and some questions are still processing (Is there a God?). So the fact that people call into question their marriages isn’t that surprising.

There was a moment—a very brief moment—when I even doubted my husband. We were both exiting at the same time, but we didn’t discuss our changing beliefs with each other much. When he brought up the idea of actually not believing, I freaked out. I had married a faithful believer, and now he’s dropping hints that maybe he might not be a believer? Who was this man? Had he been faking it all along? Can I trust him?

Those thoughts lasted about three seconds. It didn’t take much for me to remember that 1) he had, indeed, been a faithful believer; 2) he is extremely intelligent and if he’s coming to these conclusions, there must be something there; 3) he’s a really good person; and 4) he’s never given me any reason to distrust him. I also knew that I wanted to be married to this man, and I wanted it to stay that way.

When we married, the church influenced the match, yes. In fact, we wouldn’t have met had we not been Mormon: we're another BYU-dating success story. And the church influenced how quickly we got married (though we dated much longer than most BYU students).

But the church had not made our marriage. We decided to get married, and whatever the temple sealing ceremony said, we married each other in love and commitment. The interpersonal commitment to our marriage is far stronger than a covenant to some unseen God or church.

Saturday, November 11, 2006

covenant

At one point, when the church still had lots of power over me, I told my husband that I would keep the temple covenants I made, even if my beliefs about the church as the One True Church changed. Because I’d made a promise, and I have integrity enough to keep it!

Then one day I read to my son a children’s story set in Japan about a man who loved cherries. He looked forward to eating cherries for that week or so out of the year when his trees bore fruit. He generously shared his harvest with the local foxes. But one of the foxes was selfish, and schemed to trick the old man into covenanting all his trees to the fox. Eventually, the man found out he was tricked by the fox, and the fox asked for the man’s forgiveness. But the man still upheld his promise to the fox. Because a promise is a promise, after all.

I thought that was the most ridiculous reasoning on the part of the man. He had been tricked, and the repentant fox didn’t even want to hold him to the promise! Then I “likened the story unto me” and realized I was holding myself to a ridiculous covenant, too. I had made the covenants not even knowing beforehand what the covenants would be; there had been intense social pressure to go through with the covenants; and I was deceived into thinking that my entire salvation rested on the covenants.

Some TBMs are appalled to see ex-Mormons “breaking their covenants.”

But it’s not breaking covenants if the covenants simply dissolve, if they simply don’t mean anything anymore. Who had I even made the covenants with? The church? Heavenly Father? Neither held sway over me anymore. Therefore, I had made the covenants with no one but myself, and I could release myself from them.

(In the story, the fox does convince the old man to withdraw his promise, and everyone shares in the cherries once again. Cherries were shared. Smiles were smiled. Good times were had by all.)

Friday, November 10, 2006

after losing Jesus

Zarathustra put in his two cents about my post on losing Jesus. You can read his comments and my response at that link. To further clarify my response, I'm posting the second half of my short essay that began with "losing Jesus."

Religion, however, has not been completely ruined for me. I believe that all religions, including Mormonism, are people’s way of finding something bigger than themselves, however they define it: God, heaven, nirvana, peace, or harmony. I believe that ordinances, rituals, sacraments, song, sacrifices, and other forms of worship are powerfully symbolic ways for people to feel a connection with something. These acts of worship can create group solidarity, edify, heighten sense of spirituality, inspire people to be better, and serve as important rights of passage. All religions have them and all are good as long as they bring people to love and serve themselves and their fellow humans. I do not think God would care about these rituals and worship, or would demand or desire to be worshiped. Religion can be good as long as it inspires us to become better people and, especially, to treat others well, and religion is destructive when it creates manipulation, exclusion, hatred, and war. Superstition and repression of critical thinking, I suppose, are somewhere in between that simplistic spectrum of good versus destructive.

I'm searching now for a religion where I can be comfortable as a non-believer, but as someone who beliefs that myths and stories (when recognized as such) can guide and comfort us in life. Even if I don't believe in the divinity of Jesus, resurrection and the Atonement, I can still take from the stories some good ideas: forgiveness (rather than guilt), renewal, social justice. I can take from Judaism heritage, ritual, and recognition of wisdom of the elders (women included). I can take other great lessons from Taoism, Buddhism, Islam, pantheism, atheism. Just as easily, I can reject elements of those religions.

another new layout

Hmm, what do we think of this one? I had to tweak the html some. The links headlines were huge before, and right justified. And the text was bigger (sorry regina). I don't like the san-serif font for the posts, but I can't figure out how to switch it. I'd also switch the color on the title and the links headlines, but I don't know the secret codes. I tried inputting my "new name," but I guess html doesn't understand secret Mormon code.

Update: I tweaked some more things, and I like it more this way. I just can't figure out how to stop the links from being underlined. I hate them underlined.

stereotypes

There are stereotypes among Mormons about non-believers, uh, I mean, apostates. They are unfriendly, reclusive, unhappy, struggling, lost and confused. They wear immodest (and dirty) clothes, they get drunk all the time, they smoke, they drink coffee, they get multiple piercings and tattoos. They are angry, bitter, and not worth talking to. Don’t go near the apostate; she might bite. She has nothing positive to give, she’ll only suck you down into her whirlpool of spite and negativity. She doesn’t have the Spirit™.

Part of the stereotype is that as soon as someone becomes “apostate” they run out and become alcoholics, smokers, etc. As if leaving the church makes people go berserk, and they commit every sin in the 20th century book of Mormon sins.

Okay, to be fair, I do dress differently, I did start drinking alcohol, and I’m seriously considering a non-Hinckley approved piercing. But the other stuff? Just drivel.

But it wasn’t knee-jerk reaction to leaving. I didn’t just go crazy and buy a case of beer the week after I stopped going. I didn’t think, well, the restrictions are gone, so might as well.

Rather, I became free to make reasonable, rational, adult decisions for myself about these things. And after some time and de-programming, I realized coffee’s okay. Just don’t go wild. Tea is not only okay, but green tea is good for you.

Alcohol’s okay too. Just be a responsible adult about it, and carefully figure out your limits. In my Mormon mind, there was an alcohol dichotomy. It was either teetotaler or alcoholic, nothing in between. And that is just patently false. Sure, doctors say, keep the alcohol down. But “down” means no more than one drink a day for women, two for men. One candy bar a day is not healthy; one alcoholic drink a day can be. Hey, if you make it red wine, it is physically good for you.

As for clothing, that goes with people’s personal preference, the weather, the style. When I looked around, and saw that lots of people drink alcohol, tea, coffee, wear tank tops in the summer, have nose piercings, etc, I realized how totally normal all that stuff is to do. Not in an “everybody’s doing it” peer pressure kind of way, but in an “it’s just normal” kind of way.


So while “apostates” look scary, wild, and lost to Mormons, to everyone else, they just look normal.

Thursday, November 09, 2006

new layout?

What do you think of the new layout? Should I go back?

I'm not sure about the blue links. Doesn't jive with the red avatar. Any html experts can show me how to change the text color?

telling friends

Since I am so far from my old Mormon friends, my lack of P.D.B. haven’t clued in anyone about my current stance on the church. Instead, I have to confront the decision of to tell or not to tell anytime I’m going to see or talk to an old friend.

So far, I’ve only told two. Both were the types of what are called borderlanders (Sunstone term), other-believers (my term), liberal, intellectual, or internet Mormons. (I’d never explicitly labeled them or hear them label themselves, but once I was “out,” I developed a kind of other-mo-dar [in the vein of gay-dar]). They were both already exposed to exmos and had dealt with having loved ones leave. Because of that, they were pretty easy to tell. Still, telling one of them, over the phone, I cried. It was out of the blue for her, and it was the very first time I specifically verbalized to a Mormon, “I left the church.” (The other had asked, so I told.)

I was having this conversation with her about another acquaintance who left the church, and he and his wife went their respective ways because of it. I say how that's so horrible when divorce happens because of a changing belief system. And my heart is pounding out of my chest, and I'm nervous and sweating, and I'm thinking, "I can't have this kind of conversation with her without telling her about me." I stopped the conversation.

"Josie*, I have to tell you," I said significantly.
"Yes," she answered, as if she knew I had something to tell her. It was a statement, not a "Yes?"
“We’re not…in the church anymore. We’re not going.” Or something like that.

After a very short silence, she exclaimed, “From the ashes, that’s amazing!” And she was sincere. I was relieved. She understands. She’s supportive. She’s in, but out, but in herself. It was so good to tell someone who didn’t then call me to repentance or cry herself to sleep (you didn't, did you?).

I can’t imagine many of my other friends would be understanding. They won’t think it’s amazing. They won’t accept that I used my brain to come to the conclusions I did. (But that's the problem with me, isn't it? I used my brain instead of my feelings. I didn't pray about my decision and wait for a good or bad feeling. I thought about it, and decided that good or bad feelings aren't useful indicators of truthfulness.) Some of them, I imagine, will end the friendship.

And that’s sad. Really, really sad.

Have you, readers, lost friendships?

*Not her real name, but if she reads this, she'll know how I came up with it.

telling random people

I haven't gone to church in a year and a half, so I've told plenty of (never-Mormon) people I used to be Mormon. It comes up whenever someone asks me where I'm from (Utah) or where I went to college (BYU). There's just no escaping that subsequent knowing look, and the question, spoken or not, Are you Mormon? And it's pretty easy to answer, "I used to be" or "I was raised Mormon." Because to them, it doesn't really matter. It's just another talking point. Or not. Whatever. In fact, with them, it's easier for me to be not Mormon than Mormon. It's more comfortable for all of us. Mormons are, well, peculiar. And sometimes that makes people, well, uncomfortable.