Wednesday, November 08, 2006

on losing Jesus

I've found that converts to Mormonism who later leave often return to their pre-Mormon religion or belief system. I've also found that a lot of born-in-the-church ex-Mormons end up agnostic or atheist. Some convert ex-mormons can't understand the born-in ex-mormons' disbelief of Jesus. "It's not like Joseph Smith made up Jesus, so why does disbelief in Joseph's church lead to a disbelief in Jesus?" they ask.

When I was first reading "stuff on Mormonism" and realized that maybe I wouldn't always believe, I made a statement to my husband that no matter what, I would always believe in Christ and the Atonement. Now I can't believe I even made such a statement--it seems ridiculous to me.

I specifically avoided anything scholarly on Jesus while I was tearing down my Mormon world, because I knew what reading scholarly stuff did to my view of Joseph Smith. I didn't want to destroy my view of Jesus in the same way. Turns out, I didn't even read a single thing on Jesus, and my belief in his divinity just flew out the window anyway. It was partly because of all the statements Joseph made about Jesus, and I now distrust anything Joe ever said. And it was partly because of my changing world view, a more rational world view that didn't allow for miracles and resurrection, as well as a more ethical world view that refused a God who wanted his son to die. It just didn't make sense anymore.

Tuesday, November 07, 2006

one month

It's been one month since I started this blog. I've written one (or two) posts every day, had 660 hits, and 497 visitors. I've rambled, mused, posted, erased, edited, and hand-written posts when I wasn't near a computer. I've made new friends, gathered a small contingent of regular readers (Thanks, guys!), and enjoyed gaining my footing a new community.

And I finally understand the phrase "the muse that afflicts me," because sometimes, the thoughts are swirling around in my head so fast and so intrusively, that I just can't not write. It's an affliction. And I haven't gotten it out of my system yet. So here's to another month of emerging from the ashes.

And probably another.

And another.

And another.

Oh, and I'm participating in NaBloPoMo. I somehow think every day isn't going to be too hard for me.

I've coined a new term: PDB

I’ve struggled with whether to tell my old Mormon friends about my changed beliefs. I have no desire to send out a mass message to my address list saying I’ve left, as some people do. I haven’t kept in great contact with a lot of people (even good friends) from high school and college, and I don’t want them to get an email or call out of the blue that will ruin their day. Mostly, I don’t see the need to announce my personal beliefs and spirituality.

They’re personal.

But my non-faithful beliefs are personal in ways that my faithful beliefs never were. When I was Mormon, my beliefs were quite open. Too open.

The Mormon church encourages public displays of belief (P.D.B.):

There’s testimony meeting every month. Members are expected to bear their testimonies there, and at the end of lessons and talks they give.

Youth are expected to undergo interviews semiannually. Adults are expected to undergo two temple recommend interviews biannually.

Then there’s the “every member a missionary” push.

Not to mention all the faith-promoting stories about when Peter Priesthood was at work, and all his co-workers were swearing or telling dirty jokes, and he asks them to stop—“because I’m Mormon.” And his behavior is applauded in church; he stood up for what is right. (How about just walking away instead of trying to regulate every one else according to your standards?)

Or the person who was offered wine at a dinner party, and she says, “No, I don’t drink, because I’m Mormon,” and the party guests were respectful of that. And she’s sure she’ll have a convert or two from the interaction. (Guess what. A lot of people don’t drink. And they just decline the drink. They feel no need to reveal their personal reasons why they don’t drink. And people respect that.)

In all of these circumstances, Mormons are supposed to verbally proclaim their stance. If they don't engage in these behaviors, people start to wonder about their faithfulness.

Then there’s the visible P.D.B:

Garment lines (checking out people’s panty lines is not polite behavior outside of Utah)
Garment-safe clothes
Wearing white shirt and tie or dress to church
Being seen at church every Sunday
Taking the sacrament
Going to the temple
Attending temple weddings
Attending church activities

Add in the visible things you can’t do if you want to preserve your P.D.B:

Drink alcohol
Smoke
Drink coffee or tea
Go into a Starbucks or liquor store
Wear a sleeveless shirt

Then you take the combination visible/verbal P.D.B, such as where someone comments on garment lines or announces in the clothing store, “It is so hard to find shorts that are long enough!”

Growing up Mormon, I was socialized to belief that P.D.B were normal, and expected. I've had to re-teach myself that I can know someone for years without knowing their religious affiliation, and that I don't need to be blurting mine to everyone I know.

Monday, November 06, 2006

going out

Last weekend, my husband and I, along with another exmo couple, got all gussied up and went out for a night of drinking and gambling. Well, it was only sort of gambling, because gambling is illegal in my state, so it was really a fund raising event and we weren't playing with real money. Which made it really fun to put down a $1000 chip and not really worry about that fact that I just lost $100 and $200 chips in the last five rounds, and perhaps I shouldn't be risking so much with my poor luck at black jack.

In the end, I had doubled my money, and discovered I wasn't so bad at black jack. But I was terrible at craps, and was too drunk to figure out anything more than "throw the dice and make sure they hit the back wall." But, hey, with drinks only $2.50, who can resist?

The event was semi-formal, Vegas style dress up, so I went out to a consignment store with my friend to look for dresses. There were some great "little black dresses," including some I should have considered because their long sleeves and long length, given the cold November temperatures. But I just couldn't bring myself to buy anything modest. It reminded me too much of my modest Molly Mormon high school days, looking for prom dresses. Partly in reaction to that, and partly because it's just the style, I wanted something slinky. I ended up with a nice spaghetti strap black dress with an interesting, layered hem-line. I forgot to get pictures, but just trust me when I say I was hot.

The night left me in a strange limbo between feeling naughty, but not feeling guilty about it. My true-blue Mormon family would be horrified at my dress, the alcohol, and the gambling. I'm so evil, aren't I?

Sunday, November 05, 2006

a dream

I had a dream. One of my cousins was getting married in Utah, in a temple. I wasn’t planning on going to the wedding. Everyone was piling into the car to go to the airport to fly to Utah, including Mom, Grandma, Brother, and Sister, as well as Husband and Son. I got in the car just to hang out with everyone.

The driver started going. After a short drive, I said, “Wait, I’m not flying. I don’t even have my ID or a ticket or anything.” My mom said, “They won’t let you on without that stuff.” I said, “I know, I wasn’t planning on going.” They kept driving, with no plan on turning around to let me off. I said, “Just let me off and I’ll walk back.” At this point the dream was in Utah. It was somewhat far to get home, but I didn’t mind the walk. Mom started crying and said, “But everyone one of us will be there. I was expecting the whole family to be there,” meaning her, Dad, and all my siblings. I felt bad, but repeated that I didn’t have a ticket or my ID. “They won’t even let me past the security point without an ID.”

I thought, I couldn’t even go in the temple for the wedding. Then I thought, I guess I do have a recommend, I could use it, even though I’m not “worthy.” But then I thought, no, I can't do that. But I was disappointing Mom so badly by not going.

When I woke, I saw it in terms of the church. Mom is disappointed that I won’t be in the Celestial Kingdom with all the rest of them. I don’t have the right stuff, I’m not worthy, and I’m not bothering to get to the point again. I don’t want it. It’s not a big deal to me to be there—because I don’t believe it’s true, that’s all. Of course it’s a huge deal to me to be with my family, if there is such as thing as an afterlife. But I sure don’t think the Mormon version is the right one—temple recommends and secret handshakes and all that. To me, that process is a bunch of malarkey. To my parents, though, it’s everything. I’m giving them pain because they see me as rejecting life with them in the afterlife. Well, if there is an afterlife, and I don’t imagine there is, God is not so cruel as to deny me a chance to be with my family just because I won’t pay 10% of my income to the Mormons.

Saturday, November 04, 2006

why don't I stay and try to change the church?

The same friend who asked me why I don't leave church issues alone also asked me why I don't stay and try to positively change the church from within. My reply:

Any impact I could make would be very small, and only at the local level. Knowing we'll move around doesn't help us want to invest a lot into a ward only to leave it. I've never really been highly invested socially in any ward; I went because that was where I was supposed to go, not because I liked that particular community. And people don't listen. People don't go to the Mormon church to have doubts and questions thrown at them; they go for reassurance and easy answers.

To stay and work from within would require being a wolf in sheep's clothing. I'd have to make waves, but only small enough to hardly be felt so I don't get rooted out as a heretic. To have a bigger impact, I'd have to be in a leadership position (most of which are barred to me personally as a woman), but I'd really have to hide and pretend in order to achieve that position. I'd have to fake it really well, get a high position, then come out of my unbeliever's closet--causing me to loose the position, and compromise my integrity in the process. The hierarchy is set up so that changes are top-down. There are rare exceptions, i.e., when it was obvious lots of people were using birth control, the brethren cooled down about saying how evil it was; the policy change to let people have their names removed came after a lawsuit from a man who would not accept excommunication as his only way out. But mostly there is nothing I can do.

In the end of our “activity,” attendance actually made me physically ill. Nearly everything I heard make me think, “I can’t believe he/she just said that!…I don’t belong here….I don’t agree with that….That’s some serious compartmentalizing on his part.” I’d have to put up with a whole lot to stay.

Do you think people haven't tried changing the church, and have given up for many valid reasons? I desperately wanted to stay in order to help. I saw a "brain drain" where all the people actually educated about the church were leaving, so how could we ever improve it? For some people it's not worth the fight; there is just too much baggage and too much compromise of integrity and conscience to stay and support such an institution. The church just doesn't allow for a grassroots approach; it quashes "arc-steadiers," it excommunicates; it correlates.

Perhaps the very biggest reason was my child (and any future children). We just didn’t want him to be raised Mormon like we were. Getting out gives him a better chance at life. If we decide to take him to a Sunday school, it will be where he can learn love, friendship, justice, the marvels of the world, how to ask questions, how to make decisions for himself, how to define morality and make moral decisions, how to define and find his own spiritual (or non-spiritual) path, and how to help others.

We don’t want him learning obedience to authority is the first law of heaven; that people who ask questions and follow their own paths are bad; that Bible stories are literal despite major scientific and common sense knowledge to the contrary; that boys can be leaders and girls can’t; that his role in life is to bring in enough money to support his family, even if it means neglecting them; that there is a checklist for salvation; that some people (however good) are not “good enough” to see their children or siblings get married; that personal relationships are of secondary importance to church; that there is only one right way to worship; that everyone who doesn’t worship that way is wrong, misguided, or even bad; that helping others means bearing his testimony and bringing them cookies, etc. I could go on.

Being outside, I am more free to talk and say what’s on my mind, without fear of reprisal. I am free to be myself, and to find myself.

Friday, November 03, 2006

technorati

I rank 639, 287. Cool. I guess. Unless it's 639,287 out of 639, 288. Because that would suck.

Technorati Profile

why don't I leave it alone?

A Mormon saying is that people like me "leave the church, but can't leave it alone." If I've left, why do I keep blogging about it? Why do I keep reading and studying about it? Several months ago, a friend asked me these kinds of questions. The following is adapted from my reply to him.

Why still study the church? Because it had a huge impact on my life, how I think, how I feel, and who I am down to my very being, the deepest recesses of my soul. There are some things that are easy to cast off--garments, weekly attendance, daily scripture study. But deeper, there are things that are so engrained and so seemingly natural, that I don't even realize they aren't mine. It's hard to realize what is Mormon and what is not, ways of thinking, mindsets, etc. I feel I need to pick that apart, question my assumptions, and figure out who I am and what I want.

Additionally, much of what impacted me was negative. It hurt. Sometimes I feel betrayed by and angry at the church, the institution and the theology. I wonder how the church's system of socialization could be so powerful as to render me incapable for 25 years of truly questioning it. I seek to understand that.

For example, the church makes this very conversation we're having subversive and heretical. Are you feeling guilty about this exchange? Or at least like you can't talk about it openly? Many people and even churches recognize youth and young adulthood as a great time to question assumptions and authority, and to have doubts and to explore themselves and their world; they see this as not only healthy but even necessary for personal growth. I've witnessed this preached over the pulpit in a Catholic church. Some teach that doubt is an integral part of faith.

The Mormon church does not allow for that. To question and explore is not healthy and necessary, but heretical, unfaithful, dangerous, wandering in the dark and dreary wilderness, letting go of the rod, stupid, difficult, struggling with testimony, rebellious, ark-steadying, etc. It requires repentance. It is a sin. I need to understand my past, my upbringing, my family. There's plenty about the church I still want to know. There's plenty of anger and confusion and sadness I need to work through. This is why I not only read, but discuss with other ex-Mormons. Jan Schipps (a non-Mormon academic who studies Mormonism) once explained it as "ex-mormon testimony meetings." Ex-mormons like to get together and talk about Mormonism; it reinforces decisions, reassures and encourages, creates community--exactly what Mormon testimony meetings do.

The church molded me. Now I've got to remold myself, and I can't do that by ignoring the church.

Thursday, November 02, 2006

church attendance

As I stopped going to the Mormon church, it never occurred to me that I would stop going to church altogether. I had in mind that I would substitute Mormon services with some other services. I went to UU meetings a few times, and liked them a lot. I also enjoyed Quaker meeting. I attended Episcopal meetings a couple times, Catholic, even Muslim, but never really had them as options in my mind. Friends stepped up, knowing I was shopping around, and offered to introduce me to the religions that so influenced their lives.

The best part about shopping around was the lack of guilt for not attending. If I felt like going one Sunday, I went. The next, maybe not. It was wonderful to have power over my own time, guilt free.

Eventually, I stopped going regularly at all. I've been twice in the past year. Partly, I’m busy. Partly, my husband and son aren’t into services right now, and I don’t want to spend my precious alone-time on church. Partly, I don’t believe in God.

I see the value of spirituality, of edification, of the peace one can feel in services. But church isn’t the only place I can find that. Usually, I’m just as happy to seek out that peace in a bike ride with my son through the shady streets of town. Or in a hike through the woods. Or a nice sleep-in.

But lately I've needed a little more. I think I might trying attending UU again, see if I can stand the thought of organized religion yet.

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

new perspective

Now I had a whole new perspective on life, more freedom to move around, whole new ideas to consider. Everything made much more sense, and ideas fell into place like they never had before. Mormonism makes much, much more sense as a small religion started by a young, uneducated, though very imaginative and charismatic, man. It’s not how God and the world work; it’s just one (somewhat strange) way of thinking about things.

All the things I had been trying to perform painful mental gymnastics to understand—racism, sexism, polygamy—suddenly made sense if the church was just a 19th century religion.

Now that the Book of Mormon was just a 19th century creation, I could properly look at the DNA, archaeological, and logical evidence that Native Americans are descended from Asians.

Now that Genesis was just one society’s ancient origin myth, I could properly give evolution a chance. (And guess what. It makes sense.)

Now that the covenant to “hearken unto the council of my husband” was just some old guys’ revision of an even more sexist ritual, I could recover my self-esteem as a woman.

It was so refreshing to let down the compartments in my mind, to give up the mental blocks, to stop performing the mental gymnastics. At first, I had felt like my world was destroyed. Now, my life was opened up too all the splendor, the joy of discovery, the pleasure of learning. Best of all, I’ve been able to rediscover myself and figure out who I am, instead of trying to fit into a mold of what I’m supposed to be.