Thursday, November 23, 2006

happy thanksgiving

In the spirit of this day of gluttony:

Domestic goddess that I'm not, I caught up on some housework on Saturday. By the time I finished, I was in the zone and decided to cook some cinnamon rolls for dessert. When I looked up a recipe for some sugar glaze to drizzle on top, I noticed I could substitute in some liqueur. Looking through my liquor cabinet, I decided on brandy.

Not really sure if this meant our son shouldn't eat some, we jokingly debated, and decided it was such a small amount (though uncooked) that it didn't matter. At first, he was repulsed by the thought of glaze on his rolls, so I saved one for him without any. But as soon as he tasted one with glaze, he started making the coolest "yummy sounds," as if he knew exactly what was in those rolls and he was going to get away with it.

Just as we were joking about candies and desserts with alcohol in them, our son jumped up to the table and spotted the very last cinnamon roll. "Oooooohhhh," he said in ecstasy, "the last one....mmmmmmm," in a very Homer Simpson kind of way. You would have thought they'd been spiked with something a lot stronger.

Tuesday, November 21, 2006

Mountain Meadows Masscre, part 2

I finished the MMM book. While a have a few minor complaints with her work, Brooks did a pretty good job. Most importantly, she touched a part of history that others before her were either reluctant to investigate, or as she suggests, pressured to stay away from. I had already read her No Man Knows My History about Joseph Smith, and appreciated her refreshingly non-supernatural interpretation of his life.

This is my favorite paragraph from MMM:

"It seems that, once having taken a stand and put forth a story, the leaders of the Mormon church have felt that they should maintain it, regardless of all the evidence to the contrary. In their concern to let the matter die, they do not see that it can never be finally settled until it is accepted as any other historical incident, with a view only to finding the facts. To shrink from it, to discredit any who try to inquire into it, to refuse to discuss it, or to hesitate to accept all the evidence fearlessly is not only to keep it a matter of controversy, but to make the most loyal followers doubt the veracity of their leaders in presenting other matters of history."

Amen. That statement, written in 1950, is amazingly applicable to the church in 2006. Not just to the Mountain Meadows Massacre, but also to any bit of history the church ignores, hushes up, covers up, equivocates about, or downright lies about: The first vision; the origins of the Book of Mormon and Pearl of Great Price; the formation of the priesthood; the reasons why JS was jailed and murdered; the entire life and persona of Joseph Smith; changing doctrines including Adam-God and blood atonement; polygamy; racism; anti-homosexual activity; anti-equal rights activity; sexual and ecclesiastical abuse within the ranks. The full list is longer, and frustratingly so.

Mountain Meadows Masscre

So far, I've stayed away from historical subjects on the blog, but recently I decided I wanted to know more about the Mountain Meadows Massacre. This was where Mormon leaders in southern Utah basically encouraged the local Native Americans to attack a emigrant train, then offered to save the men, women, and children, but slaughtered the 120 unarmed, surrendered people instead.

So I checked a couple books out of the library. I started reading Juanita Brooks's Mountain Meadows Massacre. Here are some of my thoughts as I go through.

I found myself torn on feeling sympathetic for the Mormons as they were driven from various places in the Midwest. When I was a faithful Mormon, I found myself not caring for persecution and pioneer stories. I felt like it was talked about too much or something, like we were supposed to feel the Spirit when really what we were feeling was sympathy. And it was so one-sided. This time reading them, I could feel sorry for them as human beings--no one should have to go through that--but also finally knowing what they did to make everyone so angry at them. Not that they deserved it, but at least I could see both sides. (And I felt a little guilty about that.)

Brooks painstakingly goes through motivations, personalities, histories, movements, etc of the Mormons involved (the perpetrators). But she not only ignores Native American motives for involvement, but downright infantalizes them.

Take this quote:

"The Indians, being 'the battle-ax of the Lord,' could logically do the work, for they had no qualms about shedding blood, even innocent blood. Since the Big Mormon Chief [BY] wanted them to help with this war [against the US troops being sent from the East], here was a good place to begin. So the natives had followed and annoyed the company, happy in the sense of Mormon approval; they sent out runners to other bands for reinforcement in this thrilling and exciting game" (pp. 56-57, italics mine).

Okay, I know this was written over 50 years ago, and history really was written differently then, but sheesh. She makes the Native Americans sound like happy little puppies, eager to please their masters. Please. Surely the ones who were involved had motivation for doing so. How about bothering to find out what it was? I know the historical record would be biased toward what the Mormons were thinking rather than the Native Americans, but still.

This supposed eagerness to do the Mormons' bidding doesn't make sense in the light of the very next paragraph in Brooks's book:

"It should be remembered also that at this time the whites in the area were outnumbered more than four to one by Indians, so that the business of maintaining friendly relations was important..[she gives examples of Mormons moving into forts for protection from Indians]..In all their dealings with the Indians, both before and after the massacre, the people of the area were careful to avoid frictions lest they lead to attacks upon the scattered ranches and smaller villages" (p. 57).

Why were the Native Americans so eager to please the Mormons if they had the upper hand, as the second paragraph seems to say? Wouldn't "the business of maintaining friendly relations" be more important for the Mormons than the Native Americans?

And as far as the massacred company goes, were they really so stupid as to insult and deride the Mormons they were so dependent on for supplies in their trip through the Utah dessert? That's how Brooks unquestioningly presents them (so far anyway, I've only finished 4 chapters). Surely there is more to the company's side of the story. While Brooks certainly doesn't say the Mormons were justified in the murders, she never asks why the company wasn't more eager to keep up friendly relations with the Mormons they were so dependent on, whether they disliked them or not.

Monday, November 20, 2006

what does "Mormon" mean?

I posted previously saying "I'm not a Mormon," and generally on this blog, I refer to myself as "ex-Mormon." But I'd like to pick apart those labels a little. While I'd say that labels are never adequate to describe that complicated psyche inside each person, labels are useful, like shorthand, so I still use them.

Let's start with "Mormon."

It really depends on who you ask.

When I was a faithful, believing member of the LDS church, I considered the word Mormon to apply only to members of the LDS church, be they "active," or "inactive." I couldn't imagine that "inactives" were anything but believers who just had a few problems (with themselves) that were keeping them from coming to church. I didn't consider members of RLDS, FLDS, and any other iterations of Joseph Smith's church to be Mormon. I would venture to guess that many other LDS hold this same definition of Mormon.

As I adjusted my view of the church, I expanded the label Mormon to include any member of any church that places its origins with Joseph Smith. RLDS (now Community of Christ), FLDS, TLC, other polygamous churches, independent polygamists. All Mormon, though not LDS.

Some call Mormons, especially those with roots in Utah, an ethnic group. I didn't like that idea at first. You can't just invent an ethnic group, I thought. Ethnic groups just are. But the more I thought about it, and about the European history of (sometimes arbitrary) formation of ethnic groups in Africa, I realized that ethnic groups are by and large human made. So why not a Mormon one? What makes Mormons an ethnic group? The many generations of endogamy (marrying within the group), the distinct culture, the distinct religion, a geographic center, even a stereotype about what Mormons look like (see below).

If you ask an average American, Mormon means something particular. I never realized it until it was pointed out to me, but there is also a stereotype about what physical characteristics Mormons have. Light-haired, fair-skinned, northwestern European-looking. "Like Ken Jennings," someone told me. And while the expanding church includes people of all races and skin colors, the stereotype of Mormons as white, blond, and innocently sanguine persists. Of course, there are the stereotypes of polygamy, conservatism, innocence to the point of naivety, zealousness, wholesomeness, niceness. Like the creators of South Park said, "If we want to portray a really good, wholesome person, we make him a Mormon." (Quote from BYU NewsNet, but don't link the site from me.)

Sunday, November 19, 2006

note to self:

Always do a shot of tequila before any social function with more 2 couples.

Two shots are required before a function with more than 100 people.

I don't care if it is your son's preschool annual holiday potluck. You just can't handle it alone.

wedding day regrets

I’ve never regretted the marriage to my husband. Ever. But there was a time I was really mad about the Mormon wedding. I didn’t regret a bit of the wedding at the time it occurred. It was certainly ideal for who I was at the time. Except for the sealer’s talk before hand: booorrrrriiiiinnnngggg! And If I’d paid any attention to the words of the sealing, I would have been bothered by it. But for a faithful Molly Mormon, it was perfect.

Looking back, though, I’m angry about some things.

Not all of my family and none of my friends could be there, some because they were too young, and some because they didn’t have temple recommends for whatever reason. I regret that I thought that was okay. It was their fault, I thought, for not getting their acts together enough to get their recommends. Now I wish I would have thought of a wedding as a truly family and community event.

The words of the sealing ceremony are frustrating. There’s no mention of the word “love,” for one. And the ceremony is sexist. I “gave myself” to my husband and he “received me.” The exact words to the man are, “receive her unto yourself to be your lawful and wedded wife.” And to the woman, “give yourself to him to be his lawful and wedded wife, and for him to be your lawful and wedded husband." I wonder if the wording is there as a vestige of polygamy. I gave myself to him, so I can’t be anyone else’s wife. But he just received me, didn’t give himself, so he’s free to receive other wives? Maybe it’s not about polygamy; it which case it’s just plain sexism.

I regret that we didn’t write our own vows, or at least influence them.

I regret that I was wearing a ridiculous costume during the ceremony, and not even wearing my wedding dress.

I regret that I didn’t walk down the aisle.

I regret that we didn’t plan our own wedding according to how we wanted it.

At one brief moment, I felt like we weren’t even married, I was so mad at the church. I didn’t recognize their authority anymore, so how was my marriage valid? Then I realized that thinking that way was letting the church have authority over me still. They weren’t the ones that decided we were really married. We married each other; we recognize it, and the state recognizes it. Who cares about the church?

Saturday, November 18, 2006

if I'm out, why do I keep talking about it?

Yesterday, I wrote that, with the church, I'm either in or out. (Link to post.) I half expected for someone (a TBM troll) to comment, "If you're out, why did you still post about it every day? Aren't you still entrenched in it?" I've already posted about why I don't just leave it alone (link to post, scroll down) and why I'm blogging (link to post), but I think I have something different to say.

I'm out of the church, so why am I not out of blogging about it? To answer, let me define that "it." "It," that broad subject that encompasses everything I write about, is not the "Mormon church," or the "LDS church," or even "Mormonism." Rather, the "it" I write about is "ex-Mormonism," "recovering from Mormonism," "post-Mormonism," "what it's like to be a former Mormon, "and "my experience in and impressions of the LDS church and Mormonism, looking back at it from the point of view of an ex-Mormon."

Subtle difference? Not to me.

An ex-Mormon writing about Mormonism and an ex-Mormon writing about ex-Mormonism are very different things. You can find ex-Mormons writing about Mormonism in pro-Mormon forums, such as By Common Consent, Times and Seasons, Feminist Mormon Housewives, Sunstone, etc. From what I've seen (and I haven't seen much), some ex-Mormons will generally write in such a way that faithful Mormons wouldn't be able to identify them, or at least wouldn't be too alarmed by what they say. (I could only identify them because I know them from other venues.) They'll discuss things that aren't discussed in church, to be sure, but they talk about doctrine and issues from within the Mormon paradigm, even while they actually operate outside of it. It's an amazing talent, and it takes a certain level of "I've gotten over it" post-Mormon-ness, rather than "I'm still angry" ex-Mormon-ness.

Some would say it takes a lot of equivocating, and maybe some dishonesty. But I don't think so. It's possible to talk about fictional characters as if they existed, for example, while knowing all the while they are fictional. In fact, I would list that as a indication of well-developed characters and setting. Kudos to the author. So why not talk about Nephi, Adam, Moroni, along with Harry, Aragorn, or Mrs. Dalloway? (Not to say Nephi is a well-developed character, but you get my point, right?)

But I'm not there yet. I can't talk from within the Mormon paradigm. But I hope to be able to someday. And though I doubt I'll ever get into the Bloggernacle, I would like to be able to discuss things religious with my family and not have every word I say scream, "I'm not Mormon anymore!" Because while I'm not Mormon anymore (I could write a whole 'nother post about whether or not I am), it's conducive to productive discussion with Mormons to speak from within the paradigm.

But for this blog, I'm not trying to speak from within the Mormon paradigm. I'm trying to look back at the Mormon paradigm from the outside, from a new paradigm, and analyze who I was then and who I am now, and how I became that way.

(And why do I spend so much time defending myself?)

Friday, November 17, 2006

in or out

I know that a lot of people operate effectively in a liminal state with the church for various reasons, but for me, my personality, I’m either in or out. The transition from in to out was quite short for me. Once I stopped believing, I only attended a couple times.

So when I was in, I was in. I had a temple recommend, I read the Book of Mormon, I attended church weekly, I followed the word of wisdom. I didn’t let that stuff go until I was a non-believer. Sure, some things decreased in the months before. I didn’t read scriptures every day; I only went to the temple for weddings; I watched rated-R movies that I thought were worth my time.

The things that most obviously and significantly mark a believer from a non-believer happen to be the most superficial, too. Garment-non-safe clothes, alcohol, coffee. Those are the things I only tried as a non-believer. I’m not trying to be self-righteous about it. I’m just saying it to show how utterly indoctrinated I was, and how completely warped the church’s priorities are. The mental block against questioning the authenticity of the church’s origin claims was weaker than the mental block against questioning “alcohol is evil.”

Hello?

Thursday, November 16, 2006

Mormon neighbors

I have TBM neighbors. Some I used to go to church with. Some only know me as that inactive women, if they know my history at all. But I think they know. At the very least they’ve seen my name and address on the ward list and put two and two together. Either that, or someone has told them about me:

“You know the people in the blue house? Inactives. They used to come, give talks, hold callings, were so happy and golden, and now? They’re totally anti-social, and once, I saw her taking out the recycling—and you know what? Beer bottles.”

Yeah, the conversation probably doesn’t happen. I’m hardly a blip on their radar. But the new ones do act a little, well, scared when they see me. Like just talking to me will infect them with the lies of the devil.

Say hello, and she may make you doubt.

But I guess I should be happy that it’s not the other way—I haven’t got the bishop trying to make appointments, or the missionaries knocking on the door, or the primary president tempting my child to activities with brownies and cupcakes.

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

garments as symbol of adulthood

Garments mean many things to Mormons. One of the implicit symbols in garments is the rite of passage into adulthood. Mormons generally wear garments for the first time when they are about to go on a mission, or about to be married. Both mark significant moments in young Mormon's lives, and show with a physical object that they are now "one of us" and a full adult.

This rite of passage should be a marker of a personal and maturing relationship between the person and God, and some faithful Mormons would define it as such. This is comparable to many Muslim women's experience who, at some point in their youth or young adulthood, decide to don the veil to demonstrate their desire to follow God's will. Ideally, she is free to adopt the veil or not, and in many places, she is. But what if she doesn't veil? In some ways, she is, in effect, remaining in childhood. In some places, only little girls don't veil; women do. In a symbolic sense, she is refusing a rite of passage that would mark her as not only religious, but also as a mature adult. Hence, non-veiling Muslim women, Christians or Western tourists in a highly Muslim area may be implicitly considered non-adults, regardless of their age.

I suggest the same may be true with garments. Unlike the veil, the garments are meant to be hidden and private, and, like the veil, the spiritual act of wearing them is supposed to be intensely personal. However, there are plenty of opportunities when the fact of wearing garments becomes public, and therefore, a point on which to judge, among other things, Mormon's adulthood status.

While not as publicly visible as a veil, the garments are something of a public phenomenon among insiders, especially in Utah. Failing the garment-line test might simply mark someone as young. For example, young male BYU students who didn't demonstrate neckline “smiles” or knee-lines were dubbed pre-missionaries, or pre-mies for short. It was not lost on us that the nickname also referred to pre-mature infants. The pre-mies were either fair game for dating (for women who didn't want to find a marriage partner yet), or off-limits (for women who wanted to date only men who were of marriageable age and status). Pre-mies were not quite men.

Within the Mormon paradigm, failing the garment-line test, especially among adults out of the college years, also means something more than youthfulness. The only reason a Mormon 30-year old wouldn’t wear garments is lack of faithfulness to the church. Either she didn’t get her act together enough to go to the temple (a demonstration of immaturity), or, worse, she took her garments off (gasp!).

In Mormon-dom, children and youth don’t wear garments; adults do. Interpreted from a faithful Mormon viewpoint, taking off the garments can be considered a return to youth and immaturity. I am not arguing that it is the only interpretation. Indeed, the other connotations are undoubtedly stronger: unrighteousness, faithlessness, apostasy, covenant breaking, etc. I do suggest that because the act of donning the garments is a rite of passage into adulthood, the equally symbolic and significant act of removing the garments is rejecting that passage into adulthood.

This does not mean that people who remove their garments feel that they themselves are returning to youth, but that faithful Mormons may (subconsciously?) view them as doing so. For their part, ex-Mormons might feel they are rejecting the particular Mormon version of the rite of passage into adulthood. For them (for us), the act of removing garments marks our own version of a rite of passage into a new adulthood. One in which we can demand a more personal claim on our personal lives. We are, after all, talking about underwear.