in which Mormonism is conspicuously absent
I've been meaning for a while to comment on the section on my sidebar called "On the world, in which Mormonism is conspicuously absent." Most of the other lists of books in my sidebar include books on Mormon history, culture, theology, etc., all books I personally read during my exit process. The exception is "further reading," which includes books I've read since transitioning to my post-Mormon world that I found were relevant to my adjustment and understanding the mindrape that was Mormonism.
The "conspicuously absent" section, then, are books I read just before my world view collapsed, or only shortly thereafter, when I was still reeling from the collapse. Now, it's been two to three years since I read those books, so I don't remember all the details, but a few comments on a couple of them is in order.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies, by Jared Diamond
This book discusses major societies in each continent, their developments, and conjectures why they developed, or in some cases, why the didn't. Geography and environment are big factors in the fates of human societies, as are domesticatibility of animals and plants.
and
A Short History of Nearly Everything, by Bill Bryson
This one is an easy read (Bryson is normally a comedic travel writer), and gives some funny and interesting histories from science, from the primordial gunk that was first life, to modern theories and debates.
Very interesting in themselves but why did they affect me and my transition out of the church?
There are no Lamanites in these books.
No Nephites, no Hebrews building ships to sail to the Americas. No indication whatsoever, no blip on the screen, no unanswered questions about how a certain group of people just suddenly showed up in South America. The traditional Mormon view of how the New World was populated is 100% beneath the attention of the authors and all the anthropology, geology, paleontology, archeology, geography, linguistics, and biology that they mold together to tell the history of the Americas and the world.
Years before, that would have not worried me. I would have brushed it off as persecution (they know we have the truth, but their scientists repress it; it's all a part of Satan's plan to confuse people and fight against Heavenly Father) or ignorance (they just haven't heard the true history yet; we need to get those missionaries out there to soften their hearts).
But since I read these books when I did, when my mind was more open and doubting, they struck me like a ton of bricks.
Mormonism is insignificant in the world.
Heart of Redness, by Zakes Mda
This is the fictional story of a modern Xhosa village and how their history of the Xhosa Cattle Killing (a real life event) affects them. The Cattle Killing occurred in the 19th century in South Africa. Two young girls, who would most likely be diagnosed with schizophrenia in today's world, were treated as prophetesses visited by spirits in the 19th Xhosa village. One of their prophecies was that the Xhosa, whose entire livelihoods were keeping cattle, must kill all their cattle in order to defeat the white people and make those damn colonists just go away. If all the Xhosa people would kill their cattle, ships of powerful warriors would come from the sea to help defeat the whites. Some people believed the girls, and killed their cattle and waited. And waited. And waited for those ships to come. They never came. The believers blamed the non-believers for not killing their cattle too. Whites took power and eventually formed the apartheid government. In the fictional part of the story, set in a coastal village, a group of people resurrect the cattle killing story, forming a cult of believers who again wait and wait and wait for the coming of the ships.
Having been raised with the story of Jesus and the Second Coming, I couldn't help but see parallels. Once upon a Mormon world view, I would have interpreted this story to be an echo of the One True Story, proof that all societies once knew about Jesus. Instead, I saw Jesus and the waiting and waiting and waiting for the Second Coming to be just as ridiculous as half of this village relying on the voices of a couple schizophrenic girls from 150 years previous. They differ in time frame and scale, and Jesus, if he existed, probably wasn't schizophrenic (at least I haven't heard any theories like that), but all the same, it was a serious blow to my belief in a Second Coming.
4 comments:
I agree. It sounds lame but leaving Mormonism blew my mind! GGS is a great book. Keep the book suggestions coming!
I have heard theories that Jesus was mentally ill, delusions of grandeur, etc. and if he arrived today and started saying the things he said then, we would lock him up...(funny, I was raised episcopal/catholic and just typing that makes me want to ringe waiting for the lightning bolt to hit from above)
Oh, I just replied to tiredmormon and becca and blogger rejected my comment. Grrr. Test, test, test, 1, 2, 3.
Okay, that worked.
tiredmormon- Welcome! I loved Diamond's book, and want to read his other ones, too. I'll try to keep the book comments coming.
becca- I've heard theories like that about Jesus, now that I've thought about it. I haven't really read anything about him (outside the Bible). I managed to lose my faith in his divinity without having read anything.
Many Mormons believe that if Jesus showed up to church, he'd be kicked out. And I know what you mean about the lightning bolt. Jesus used to be so sacred to me that I never even called him Jesus. It was always Jesus Christ or Christ of the Savior, etc.
Post a Comment